Here are the records for all of the BCS/P5 head football coaches hired within the last decade, FWIW. Some of these records were chopped off at the conclusion of 2015, but you get the point. A real mixed bag of results, across the spectrum.
Mike Sherman 25-25
Kevin Sumlin 42-16
Bobby Petrino 34-17 (.667 win %, Nutt had a .610 at Arkansas)
John L. Smith 4-8
Brett Bielema 24-23
Les Miles 114-34 (.770 win %. Saban had a .750 w LSU)
Barry Odom 2-7
Joker Philips 13-24 (100 points worse winning % than Rich Brooks)
Mark Stoops 7-17
Lane Kiffin 7-6
Derek Dooley 15-21
Butch Jones 20-17
Robbie Caldwell 2-10
James Franklin 24-15
Derek Mason 3-9
Ed Orgeron 10-25
Houston Nutt 24-26
Hugh Freeze 35-19 (.648 %, Cutcliffe was .603)
Sylvester Croom 21-38
Dan Mullen 55-35
Nick Saban 100-18
Gene Chizik 33-19
Gus Malzahn 34-15 (only 14% points higher than Tubberville at Auburn)
Kirby Smart 5-4
Will Muschamp 28-21
Jim McElwain 10-3
Will Muschamp 5-4
Rich Rodriguez 35-21
Dennis Erickson 31-30
Todd Graham 34-19
Lane Kiffin 28-15
Steve Sarkisian 12-6
Clay Helton 12-7
Rick Neuheisel 21-29
Jim Mora 40-22
Sonny Dykes 18-26
Jim Harbaugh 29-21
David Shaw 57-14
Chip Kelly 46-7
Mark Helfrich 36-14
Gary Anderson 2-10
Steve Sarkisian 34-29
Chris Peterson 24-12
Paul Wolf 9-40
Mike Leach 28-31
Kyle Whittingham 99-46
Dan Hawkins 16-33
Jon Embree 4-21
Mike MacIntyre 17-29
Art Briles 39-30
Jim Grobe 6-2
Charlie Strong 16-18
Tommy Tubberville 20-17 (Leach was 84-43 w Tech)
Kliff Kingsbury 23-24
Mike Gundy 101-49
Bill Stewart 28-12
Dana Holgerson 43-29
Ron Prince 17-20
Bill Snyder 62-37
Turner Gill 5-19
Charlie Weis 6-22
David Beaty 1-20
Gene Chizik 5-19
Paul Rhoads 32-55
Matt Campbell 1-8
Bill Callahan 27-22
Bo Pelini 67-27
Mike Riley 13-9
Tim Brewster 15-30
Jerry Kill 29-29
Tracy Claeys 9-6
Brett Bielema 68-24
Gary Anderson 19-7
Paul Chryst 17-5
Rich Rodriguez 15-22
Brady Hoke 31-20
Jim Harbaugh 19-3
Mark Dantonio 89-40
Danny Hope 22-27
Darrell Hazell 9-33
Bill Lynch 19-30
Kevin Wilson 25-45
Pat Fitzgerald 74-61
Ron Zook 34-51
Tim Beckman 12-25
Bill Cubit 5-7
Lovie Smith 3-6
Urban Meyer 58-5
Bill O’Brien 15-9
James Franklin 21-14
Kyle Flood 27-24
Chris Ash 2-7
Randy Edsall 22-33
D.J. Durkin 5-4
Greg Robinson 5-37
Doug Marrone 25-25
Scott Shafer 14-23
Dino Babers 4-5
Dave Wannstedt 42-31
Todd Graham 6-6
Paul Chryst 19-19
Pat Narduzzi 13-9
Mike London 27-46
Bronco Mendenhall 2-7
Butch Davis 28-23
Everett Withers 7-6
Larry Fedora 39-22
Tom O’Brien 40-35
Dave Doeren 22-25
Jeff Jagodzinski 20-8
Frank Spaziani 22-29
Steve Addazio 21-26
Dave Clawson 12-21
Dabo Sweeney 84-27
Paul Johnson 66-48
Jimbo Fisher 74-17
Randy Shannon 28-22
Al Golden 32-25
Mark Richt 5-4
Steve Kragthorpe 15-21
Charlie Strong 37-15
Bobby Petrino 66-19
Mike Sherman 25-25
Kevin Sumlin 42-16
Bobby Petrino 34-17 (.667 win %, Nutt had a .610 at Arkansas)
John L. Smith 4-8
Brett Bielema 24-23
Les Miles 114-34 (.770 win %. Saban had a .750 w LSU)
Barry Odom 2-7
Joker Philips 13-24 (100 points worse winning % than Rich Brooks)
Mark Stoops 7-17
Lane Kiffin 7-6
Derek Dooley 15-21
Butch Jones 20-17
Robbie Caldwell 2-10
James Franklin 24-15
Derek Mason 3-9
Ed Orgeron 10-25
Houston Nutt 24-26
Hugh Freeze 35-19 (.648 %, Cutcliffe was .603)
Sylvester Croom 21-38
Dan Mullen 55-35
Nick Saban 100-18
Gene Chizik 33-19
Gus Malzahn 34-15 (only 14% points higher than Tubberville at Auburn)
Kirby Smart 5-4
Will Muschamp 28-21
Jim McElwain 10-3
Will Muschamp 5-4
Rich Rodriguez 35-21
Dennis Erickson 31-30
Todd Graham 34-19
Lane Kiffin 28-15
Steve Sarkisian 12-6
Clay Helton 12-7
Rick Neuheisel 21-29
Jim Mora 40-22
Sonny Dykes 18-26
Jim Harbaugh 29-21
David Shaw 57-14
Chip Kelly 46-7
Mark Helfrich 36-14
Gary Anderson 2-10
Steve Sarkisian 34-29
Chris Peterson 24-12
Paul Wolf 9-40
Mike Leach 28-31
Kyle Whittingham 99-46
Dan Hawkins 16-33
Jon Embree 4-21
Mike MacIntyre 17-29
Art Briles 39-30
Jim Grobe 6-2
Charlie Strong 16-18
Tommy Tubberville 20-17 (Leach was 84-43 w Tech)
Kliff Kingsbury 23-24
Mike Gundy 101-49
Bill Stewart 28-12
Dana Holgerson 43-29
Ron Prince 17-20
Bill Snyder 62-37
Turner Gill 5-19
Charlie Weis 6-22
David Beaty 1-20
Gene Chizik 5-19
Paul Rhoads 32-55
Matt Campbell 1-8
Bill Callahan 27-22
Bo Pelini 67-27
Mike Riley 13-9
Tim Brewster 15-30
Jerry Kill 29-29
Tracy Claeys 9-6
Brett Bielema 68-24
Gary Anderson 19-7
Paul Chryst 17-5
Rich Rodriguez 15-22
Brady Hoke 31-20
Jim Harbaugh 19-3
Mark Dantonio 89-40
Danny Hope 22-27
Darrell Hazell 9-33
Bill Lynch 19-30
Kevin Wilson 25-45
Pat Fitzgerald 74-61
Ron Zook 34-51
Tim Beckman 12-25
Bill Cubit 5-7
Lovie Smith 3-6
Urban Meyer 58-5
Bill O’Brien 15-9
James Franklin 21-14
Kyle Flood 27-24
Chris Ash 2-7
Randy Edsall 22-33
D.J. Durkin 5-4
Greg Robinson 5-37
Doug Marrone 25-25
Scott Shafer 14-23
Dino Babers 4-5
Dave Wannstedt 42-31
Todd Graham 6-6
Paul Chryst 19-19
Pat Narduzzi 13-9
Mike London 27-46
Bronco Mendenhall 2-7
Butch Davis 28-23
Everett Withers 7-6
Larry Fedora 39-22
Tom O’Brien 40-35
Dave Doeren 22-25
Jeff Jagodzinski 20-8
Frank Spaziani 22-29
Steve Addazio 21-26
Dave Clawson 12-21
Dabo Sweeney 84-27
Paul Johnson 66-48
Jimbo Fisher 74-17
Randy Shannon 28-22
Al Golden 32-25
Mark Richt 5-4
Steve Kragthorpe 15-21
Charlie Strong 37-15
Bobby Petrino 66-19
